Opens in a new tab

Freelancer vs Marketing Consultant: Who to Hire First

The freelancer vs marketing consultant choice comes down to whether you already know what needs to get made. If you can describe the finished piece, when it’s due and how you’ll judge it, hire a freelancer. If you’re still guessing which piece would help, talk to a consultant first, because a freelancer will build exactly what you asked for, and that only works if you asked for the right thing.

Below is how the 2 jobs differ and a 5-line brief that tells you whether you’re ready.

Freelancer vs Marketing Consultant: What Each One Is Hired to Do

A freelancer gets hired to make a specific thing. A landing page, a set of photos, 8 blog posts, a Google Ads account. A consultant gets hired to decide which of those things are worth making and what order they go in, and a lot of us don’t make them at all.

I’m in that second group. I don’t build websites, run ads or do design work. When a plan needs that kind of execution, I bring in trusted partners and stay on the strategy side so the work stays tied to the plan.

The IRS definition of an independent contractor describes someone whose client has the right to control or direct only the result of the work, and not what will be done and how. Your CPA can tell you what that means for your books. The business read is that somebody has to define the result before the work starts, and that part usually lands back on you.

When a Freelancer Is the Right Hire

A freelancer is the right hire when the thinking is already done and one piece is missing. Say you run an HVAC company, you know maintenance plans are what you want to sell, the offer is written, and all you’re missing is a page to send people to. Hire someone who makes great pages. Paying me to tell you what you already know would be a waste of your money.

I have a lot of respect for the good ones, too. My co-founder at my old agency was a full-time freelancer when we partnered up, and we started out of my living room. Someone who has spent years on one craft will usually beat a generalist at it.

The 5-Line Brief That Tells You If You’re Ready

Before you hire a freelancer, write a one-page brief with 5 lines on it. The first line is the finished result, in a sentence someone else could check. The second is why this piece comes ahead of everything else you could fix right now. The third lists the access they’ll need, logins and whatever photos are stuck on your phone. The fourth names the one person who approves the work. The last is the number you’ll look at 60 days later to decide whether it paid off.

Run it on that HVAC page. The result is a maintenance plan page with a form that lands in the office manager’s inbox. It comes first because the offer is ready. The freelancer needs the website login and 3 good photos of the crew. The owner approves it. And the number is plan signups from that page after 60 days. That fits on half a page.

If you stall on the second line or the last one, you’ve found a strategy question, which a freelancer wasn’t hired to answer.

Hiring Several Freelancers With No Plan Makes You the Project Manager

The expensive version of this is hiring a web person, an ads person and a social person one at a time, because each one solved whatever was loudest that month. Each of them can do honest work and you still end up with an ad promising one thing and a website saying something else.

Nobody in that setup was hired to care how the pieces fit, so that job falls to you, at night, after the actual work is done. Every invoice looks reasonable on its own. Then you add them up a year later and can’t say what they bought.

Whoever you hire, keep the files and logins in your name and get it in writing who owns the finished work. The same marketing contract red flags apply to a freelancer’s one-page agreement.

Hire the Consultant First When You Can’t Name the Piece

Go to a consultant first when you know something’s off and can’t say which piece would fix it. Leads went soft, the website might be the problem or might not, and 3 people have told you 3 different things. Each order has a cost. Freelancer first gets something finished fast, and you carry the risk that it was the wrong something. Consultant first means paying for thinking before you have anything to look at, and if you already knew the answer, that’s money you didn’t need to spend.

What you want out of a consultant is, in effect, that 5-line brief for every piece, in the right order. Then you can hire freelancers against it. If you’d rather have it built than manage it, the Foundation Accelerator puts in the lead flow and content system the plan called for, then documents it and trains your team to run it. If you’re also weighing an agency, here’s what a marketing consultant and an agency are each paid to do.

Write the 5 Lines Before You Hire Anyone

Try those 5 lines tonight. If they come easy, go find a good freelancer. If you get stuck, bring what you’ve got to a 30-minute Clarity Discovery Call on Google Meet or at my office in Pocatello, and we’ll work out what the first piece should be.

Related posts